23 Sep Dealing With Insurance Companies After an Injury: What They Don’t Want You to Know
Don’t face the insurance company alone. Call Gruenberg Kelly Della for a free case evaluation — 24/7. No fee unless we win. $100M+ recovered for Long Island injury victims.
After an injury, the insurance company will contact you. They will sound helpful. They will express concern for your well-being. They will tell you the process is simple and that they just want to get things sorted out quickly.
What they don’t tell you is that everything in that conversation, and every conversation that follows, is oriented toward one goal: paying you as little as possible.
Insurance companies are for-profit businesses. Their claims adjusters are trained professionals whose performance is measured, in part, by how little they pay out. They are not your advocates. They are not neutral parties. And they are not on your side, even if they act like they are.
This guide explains exactly how insurance companies operate after an injury, the specific tactics they use to minimize claims, and how having an attorney levels the playing field.
How the Insurance Claims Process Actually Works
After an accident or injury, a claims adjuster is assigned to your case. The adjuster’s job is to investigate the claim, assess liability, and determine what the insurance company will pay. They are employed by, and loyal to, the insurance company.
Adjusters are often experienced, skilled negotiators who handle dozens of claims simultaneously. They know the applicable law, the local court tendencies, and the typical value of cases like yours. They have handled thousands of claims. Most injury victims have never navigated this process before.
This asymmetry of experience and information is one of the primary reasons unrepresented claimants consistently recover less than represented claimants, often significantly less, even after accounting for attorney fees.
The 9 Tactics Insurance Companies Use to Minimize Your Claim
1. The Early Lowball Offer
One of the most common tactics is contacting you quickly, sometimes within 24 to 48 hours of the accident, with a settlement offer. The timing is deliberate. You are still in shock, potentially in the hospital, and likely haven’t yet understood the full extent of your injuries.
These early offers are almost always far below the true value of the claim. They are designed to close your case before you retain an attorney, before your injuries are fully diagnosed, and before you understand what you may be entitled to recover. Once you accept a settlement and sign a release, your claim is gone, even if you later discover your injuries are more serious than you initially knew.
Never accept an early settlement offer without consulting an attorney.
Even if the offer sounds reasonable, accepting it requires signing a release of all future claims. Once signed, you cannot go back, even if your condition worsens significantly.
2. The Recorded Statement Trap
Shortly after the accident, an adjuster from the at-fault party’s insurance company may call and ask for a recorded statement. They may say it’s just routine, that they need to hear your account, or that it will help move things along faster.
Do not give a recorded statement to another party’s insurer without first speaking to an attorney. Adjusters are trained to ask questions in ways that can:
- Elicit admissions of partial fault (“Were you looking at your phone?”, “Were you in a hurry?”)
- Get you to minimize your injuries early (“How are you feeling today?” early in treatment can be used against you later when your injuries worsen or prove more serious than initially apparent)
- Create inconsistencies that can be used to challenge your account at trial
You are not legally required to give a recorded statement to the other party’s insurer. You may be contractually required to cooperate with your own insurer, but even then, it is best to have an attorney present or, at minimum, review the questions first.
3. Disputing the Severity of Your Injuries
Insurance companies scrutinize medical records aggressively, looking for any basis to argue that your injuries are less severe than you claim. Common arguments include:
- Pre-existing conditions. “Your MRI shows disc degeneration that predates the accident; your current symptoms are pre-existing, not caused by our insured.” New York law allows recovery for aggravation of pre-existing conditions, but the defense will make this argument aggressively.
- Soft tissue skepticism. Injuries like whiplash, muscle strains, and herniated discs that don’t appear on imaging are harder to document and routinely minimized by adjusters as subjective complaints.
- Treatment gaps. If you missed appointments, delayed seeking care, or stopped treatment before reaching maximum medical improvement, the insurer will argue this proves your injuries weren’t serious.
This is one reason why consistent, well-documented medical care from the earliest possible point after an injury is so important, both for your health and your case.
4. The Independent Medical Examination
Despite the word “independent,” an IME (Independent Medical Examination) ordered by an insurance company is anything but neutral. The physicians who perform these examinations are retained and compensated by the insurance industry. Studies consistently show that IME physicians render opinions favorable to the insurer at rates far exceeding what would be expected from a truly independent evaluation.
In New York no-fault cases, you are typically required to attend an IME scheduled by your insurer. In third-party claims, an IME may be ordered during litigation. Knowing what to expect from this process, and how to document and challenge an unfavorable IME, is something an experienced personal injury attorney handles.
5. Surveillance
For larger claims, particularly those involving serious or permanently disabling injuries, insurance companies sometimes hire private investigators to conduct surveillance. This may include:
- Photographing or videotaping you during daily activities
- Monitoring your social media accounts for photos or posts that suggest greater physical capability than your claimed limitations
- Canvassing your neighborhood to speak with people who might comment on your activities
This is not illegal, but it is something to be aware of. If you have claimed serious limitations from your injury, be thoughtful about what you post publicly. A photo from a family event that makes it look like you’re feeling fine can be taken out of context and used to undermine your claim.
6. Delay Tactics
Insurance companies sometimes deliberately delay the claims process in hopes that financial pressure will force an injured claimant to accept less than they deserve. Medical bills accumulate, lost wages create hardship, and the offer that seemed too low six months ago starts to look more attractive when you’re struggling financially.
When Gruenberg Kelly Della represents you, insurance companies know that delay strategies don’t work; we have the resources to sustain litigation as long as necessary to get you what you deserve. And if they drag things out unreasonably, we can seek additional damages for bad faith handling of the claim.
7. Disputing Causation
Even when liability is clear, even when the other driver ran a red light or the property owner’s negligence is documented, the insurer may argue that your injuries were not caused by the accident. This is especially common when:
- There was a delay between the accident and when you sought medical treatment
- You have a history of prior treatment for the same body part
- Your injuries are of the type that can have multiple causes (back pain, headaches, anxiety)
Medical documentation that clearly establishes the connection between the accident and your injuries, created close in time to the accident, is one of the most important elements of a strong personal injury case.
8. Using Your Own Words Against You
Adjusters are trained to listen carefully to everything you say and look for statements that can be used to minimize your claim. This includes:
- Apologies at the scene. “I’m so sorry” is a natural human response after an accident. It can be used as an admission of fault.
- Minimizing statements. “I’m okay, I think” or “It’s probably nothing” said immediately after an accident can later be used to argue your injuries weren’t serious.
- Social media posts. Anything you post publicly after an injury- a comment, a photo, a check-in- can be used as evidence against you.
The safest approach after any accident is to say as little as possible until you have spoken with an attorney.
9. Exploiting the Unrepresented Claimant
Insurance adjusters know that unrepresented claimants are less likely to know the full value of their claim, less likely to understand their legal rights, and less likely to pursue litigation if a settlement offer is inadequate. They negotiate differently, and less generously, with unrepresented claimants than with attorneys they know and respect.
This is documented by multiple studies. Claimants represented by attorneys consistently recover more than unrepresented claimants, even after accounting for attorney fees. The contingency fee model exists precisely because access to experienced representation should not be limited to people who can afford to pay hourly.
How an Attorney Changes the Dynamic
When Gruenberg Kelly Della represents you, the relationship with the insurance company changes fundamentally.
All communication goes through us; adjusters can no longer call you directly, ask for recorded statements, or make direct settlement offers designed to take advantage of your inexperience. We handle all of it.
Insurance companies also know our firm’s reputation. They know we have the resources, expertise, and willingness to take cases to trial in Nassau County and Suffolk County courts. That knowledge affects how they evaluate your claim from the first contact. A firm with a documented trial record commands more respect and better offers than a firm that always settles.
We document your damages completely. We work with medical experts, economists, and vocational specialists as needed to build a comprehensive picture of what your injury has cost you and will cost you in the future. We present this to the insurer with a clear demand backed by evidence. We negotiate aggressively. And if the insurer refuses to make a fair offer, we litigate.
What to Do — and What Not to Do — After an Injury
Do:
- Seek medical attention immediately and follow your doctor’s treatment plan consistently
- Document the accident scene with photographs if you are physically able
- Get the names and contact information of any witnesses
- Report the accident to your own insurer as required by your policy
- Keep records of all medical bills, prescription receipts, and other expenses
- Keep a journal of your symptoms, treatment, and how the injury affects your daily life
- Contact a personal injury attorney before giving any statement to any insurer
Don’t:
- Give a recorded statement to the other party’s insurer without first speaking to an attorney
- Accept any settlement offer without consulting an attorney, even if it sounds fair
- Post on social media about your accident, your injuries, or your activities during recovery
- Apologize or admit fault at the scene
- Delay seeking medical care; gaps in treatment hurt your case
- Assume the insurance company is looking out for your best interests
Frequently Asked Questions
My own insurance company is being difficult. Can they do that?
Unfortunately, yes, your own insurer has financial incentives to minimize payouts just as the other party’s insurer does. This is particularly common in uninsured motorist claims (where your own policy covers you for an at-fault uninsured driver) and no-fault benefit disputes. Your insurance policy is a contract, and you have legal rights under it. An attorney can help you enforce those rights.
The adjuster said my claim is worth X. Is that right?
Almost certainly not, or at least not the full picture. Adjusters are trained to present numbers that favor the insurance company. The true value of a personal injury claim depends on medical expenses, lost wages, pain and suffering, future damages, and many other factors that a quick adjuster’s estimate rarely captures fully. Get an attorney’s assessment before accepting any number as accurate.
What if I already gave a recorded statement?
It’s not ideal, but it doesn’t necessarily end your case. What you said matters, and an experienced attorney can work with the statement, explaining context, highlighting inconsistencies in how the question was framed, and building evidence that supports your account. Contact an attorney as soon as possible after giving a statement you’re concerned about.
How long does it take for an insurance company to make a fair offer?
With representation from a firm they respect, often faster than without. Insurance companies delay and lowball unrepresented claimants because they can. When they know they’re dealing with Gruenberg Kelly Della, a firm with a trial record in Nassau and Suffolk County courts — the negotiating dynamic changes.
For more information about how New York personal injury claims work — including the statute of limitations, what your case may be worth, and how to choose the right attorney, visit our Complete Guide to Personal Injury Claims in New York.
Don’t Talk to the Insurance Company Without a Lawyer.
Free case evaluation — available 24/7 — no fee unless we win
Call Gruenberg Kelly Della or submit online at newyorklawgroup.com
Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. All case results depend on the specific facts and legal circumstances of each matter. This article is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading this content does not create an attorney-client relationship with Gruenberg Kelly Della.